Register Login
Cecelia Schmidt
(631) 897-6938
Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    31
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 41 ratings.
21 user reviews.
Includes 10 Zillow reviews
Photo of Cecelia Schmidt
Cecelia Schmidt

I found Cecelia to be very knowledgeable, personable, and helpful

Adrienne Spinelli

Cecelia is a professional and did exactly what she was hired to do. Plus, she can put up with me and my crazy life. Win win!

Benjamin Lieberman

Ceceila was great! she is my realtor of choice.

Joseph Petrocelli

We have had Cecilia help us buy and sell a few homes and she is an absolute pleasure. Her knowledge of the market combined with her professionalism and responsiveness made our home search smooth and stress free. We highly recommend her!

Kathleen Petrocelli

Cecilia was so great. She spent the time to meet with my wife and I to understand what we were looking for in our new home. She spent many conversations to do this and ended up finding the house for us after going out on one weekend.

Christopher Martin

Cecilia is extremely professional and definitely knowledgeable. We have used Cecilia before and we will use her again.

Kathleen Petrocelli, Smithtown, NY | Home Seller

We used Cecelia to purchase our home 28 years ago. From that moment we knew we would use her to sell the home when we were ready. 28 years later we did just that!

Carol & Steven Wasserman, Commack NY | Home Seller

Cecelia is a consummate professional. Her knowledge and expertise proved to be invaluable. Every suggestion she gave us was spot on and we were able to sell our house quickly because of it. We highly recommend Cecelia!

Gina Barnett, Smithtown, NY | Home Seller

Cecelia Schmidt was very helpful throughout the entire selling process. She either picked up the phone immediately or quickly responded to phone calls and text messages. Always warm, friendly, and responsive to any request, Cecelia reduced the stress involved with selling a home. She is extremely knowledgeable, professional, and attentive to the sellers and the prospective buyers all at the same time. I would highly recommend Cecelia to anyone thinking about selling their home.

Joan, Commack, NY | Home Seller

One of Cecelia's strengths is her doggedness. Nothing can throw her off target, and that determination was very helpful to us.

Amy Grodin | Home Seller

How refreshing in these times to find a person who takes pride in their profession. Cecelia goes the extra mile for her client. She is extremely knowledgeable in her field and takes her job very seriously. Always a phone call away for any questions and concerns. Cecelia was a pleasure to work with and you'll be certain she always has your best interests in mind.Thank you Cecelia, for making a differcult task smooth.

Janet Fiore- Brentwood | Home Seller

My friend, who highly recommended Cecelia and who had worked with her through the law firm she worked at, was all there recommendation I needed. I completely trusted my friend and transferred that trust to Cecelia. I was not disappointed. I live out of state and after meeting with Cecelia when we initially set up the discussion to put my father's house on the market, I was completely impressed with not only her knowledge and professionalism but also the warm feeling that she totally cares about her clients and truly wants them to have the best experience possible when going through the emotional and stressful time of selling the home you grew up in to someone else. Cecelia is amazing. She helped my brothers and I through every phase and issue encountered. All with a smile and caring demeanor. I am so thankful she was recommended to me. Cecelia is the best! Even with the issues that arose from the inspection everything was handled professionally and smoothly with fair and honest negotiations and advice at every turn. My brothers and especially myself were very pleased to have her in our corner. I can't say enough about what it meant to me to know that no matter when I needed to contact her she was always there or called me back almost immediately. Being from out of state I knew I could depend on her to keep me well informed on what was going on with every aspect of the sale. I am very thankful. Selling my parents home, the place where I grew up, was very hard and very emotional. I could not hang on to it and had to sell. Cecelia knew how hard it was and gave my brothers and I the most seamless and comforting experience so we would be ok when we had to finally let our childhood home go to someone else.

Pat Mjos, Groton, MA for my parents home in Smithtown NY | Home Seller

We were not expecting to sell so fast and to have so many offers but she knew exactly what to do Dedicated, smart, professional. I would use her again any time and recommend to anyone selling.

Loretta Gallion | Home Seller

We loved working with Cecelia as we searched for and purchased our first home. She was patient, knowledgable, and always a pleasure to communicate with. Her contacts in the industry were also of great value, and led to us securing our first mortgage. Perhaps most importantly, she was never pushy and worked with us to find a home that met all of our needs. I would never hesitate to recommend Cecelia to anyone looking to purchase a new home. Thank you, Cecelia!

Cecelia is an excellent realtor who knows how to market a house for a quick sale. She provided me with good advice throughout the process and was always available. The house sold above the asking price with multiple offers. Cecelia has very good resources and gave me the names and telephone numbers of contacts, who I then hired to prep the house before selling it. Her advice resulted in a sale over the asking price. She was always available to answer any questions and give me advice. She was a pleasure to work with, and I would recommend her without hesitation.

M. Gilmartin, Centerport | Home Seller

Cecelia Schmidt is an excellent realtor who goes above and beyond! She is very personable, thorough and communicative. She was with me and my husband every step of the way and always available. In this crazy housing market, Cecelia calmed our fears, answered our questions and helped us to navigate and find our dream home!! We highly recommend Cecelia- a true professional and expert.

Mary Ann A., Nesconset | Home Buyer

If you want to sell your home in Saint James, Smithtown area - call Cecelia schmidt @Coldwell Banker American Homes - Smithtown. She is a realestate expert, honest, professional, kind, easy to work with, and so much more that you will find out when you call her. A+ Thank you for your services!

Sarah Kessler, Saint James NY | Home Seller

Cecelia Schmidt was easily accesabile and answered all questions and concerns. I would definitely recommend her to others.

K Smithtown | Home Seller

Cecelia Schmidt simply is a professional who's working knowledge of the Smithtown area was very important to me. She arrived at our first meeting prepared to help me understand not just the market but how to show and price my house to gain buyer interest in an expeditious manner. Cecelia had a winning game plan and was able to articulate it clearly to me. The other realtors I interviewed were just listing a house. Cecelia was teaming with me to sell my home! She was and is everything you could want in a realtor!I couldn't have asked for more. In addition to the regular MLS listing, Cecelia showcased my home as the "home of the week" giving it extra exposure. For me, it was above and beyond my expectations! Cecelia kept me in the loop every step of the way. Additionally, I really appreciated all of the recommendations Cecelia made to help me through the process (professional photographer, attorney, movers). Cecelia not only rounded out the team to make my life easier, she used a network of professional women that I was super happy with!Cecelia encompasses all of the characteristics one could want/expect from a realtor. From start to finish Cecelia was accessible and helped guide me throughout the process. She was the glue to everything involving the sale of my property.You cannot go wrong with Cecelia Schmidt! She has the experience and knowledge needed to navigate whatever the market may be at the time one may be either buying or selling. I believe this because I personally experienced working with her, but also because Cecelia has been in the business long enough to have worked through the ups and downs of this real estate industry and has clearly remained in the forefront as a successful realtor.

Liz D'Alesandro Smithtown, NY | Home Seller

Cecilia Schmidt was very responsive, proactive and knowledgeable in the selling process for us.

Russell Snaith, Hauppauge | Home Seller

Cecelia is a firecracker! She is really good at what she does and informs you of all things going with your home. She does everything in her power to get your home sold fast. Again, nothing but an outstanding performance, easy to work with &Rocky professional.She was outstanding both times we have used her services.

Rocky & Linda | Home Seller

I have known Cecelia Schmidt for over a decade now . My wife and I met Cecelia when we were looking for our first home and after having a bad experience with another agent . We met told Cecelia our needs gave her our parameters and she went to work . She took us to so many homes and never gave up and ultimately we found our home . Since then we have become friends being that we are from the same area and I recommend her to whoever needs an agent . I consider her family and when it was time to sell my childhood home there was never a thought as to who I was going with . Cecelia knows the market and has the pulse on our community and now I was able to close this chapter in my life. She is professional, courteous,funny,tenacious and most of all trustworthy and I value her opinion.Sincerely, Anthony Mangini

Anthony Mangini Nesconset | Home Seller

Cecilia is a very knowledgeable and professional realtor, my property was sold in less then 2 weeks thanks to her. I would be happy to recommend her to anyone that is looking to sell or buy their next home

My husband and I were thrilled with Cecelia and our experience with Cecelia was a positive one. She was very responsible and available to us. There are a lot of ups and downs with purchasing a home and Cecelia helped us navigate through it and make the experience less painful. She was very strong when it came to making an offer and provided guidance on what to do in order to secure the house even though there were multiple offers. I would highly recommend using Cecelia.

Very knowledgeable person in all areas when it comes to buying a house. Pleasant to do business with and never to busy to answer questions. I was pleased to have her as my agent.

Cecelia Schmidt is an excellent real estate agent. She is knowledgeable, experienced, honest and most importantly she delivers!She Sold our house promptly and efficiently. We couldn’t have find a better agent

Cecelia was absolutely amazing! She went above and beyond to find us our dream home! We gave her a list of must have in our home with a budget we wanted to stay in, she found exactly what we were looking for within our budget! We highly recommend Cecelia to anyone who is looking for a home!

We found Cecelia to be the consummate professional and was the ideal Agent to help us sell our home, a home we had been in for 34 years. She knew exactly what to do, and when to do it, through every step of the process. Ultimately securing almost a dozen offers, over asking price, and within just a few days. We highly recommend her!

Bob Unger

Cecelia helped us list/sell 2 homes and purchase a home during the summer of 2020...all in the midst of COVID. Coordinating the sale of 2 homes with the purchase of another can be quite stressful and timing of all activities is key. Cecelia worked tirelessly throughout the process and always made us feel confident we'd get it done and kept us focused on the end result. She is very knowledgeable about the market and has a good sense of the right price point to list at to generate buzz/interest and sell quickly. Thanks to Cecelia, both houses sold over asking price...and she helped us find the home of our dreams!

Cecelia is hard working, enduring, and congenial. During a pandemic and the craziest market we've seen in a while, she helped me look for 6 months to find my first house. She was very responsive whether it was text or email. Seller's agents knew I meant business whenever I mentioned she was my agent. Would definitely recommend, it was a pleasure.

Working with Cecelia was awesome. She guided us in preparing our home to sell. She was very knowledgeable of the complex rules and requirements. She always made herself available to answer any questions. Plus she always called with updates regarding our property or even how the overall real estate market was doing in general. We would highly recommend her.

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
©2024 1864 Hempstead Turnpike Realty Inc. All rights reserved. Coldwell Banker® and the Coldwell Banker Logo are registered service marks owned by Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. 1864 Hempstead Turnpike Realty Inc. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with or related to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 06/16/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 06/16/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Tue 06/16/2026 12:08:27 PM EST) or OneKey MLS (last updated Tue 06/16/2026 12:06:44 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker American Homes may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel